4th Circuit Case Commentaries

Title VII Protects Individually Discerned “Body-as-a-Temple” Vaccine Objections; Mixed Motives and “Personal Decision” Language Do Not Defeat a Prima Facie Case at Summary Judgment

Date: Sep 3, 2026

Title VII Protects Individually Discerned “Body-as-a-Temple” Vaccine Objections; Mixed Motives and “Personal Decision” Language Do Not Defeat a Prima Facie Case at Summary Judgment Case: Delsonya...

Fourth Circuit Reaffirms: No Fourth Amendment Privacy in a Stolen Vehicle Absent Innocent Acquisition; Broad Appeal Waivers Enforced While Preserved Suppression Issues Remain Reviewable

Date: Sep 3, 2026

Fourth Circuit Reaffirms: No Fourth Amendment Privacy in a Stolen Vehicle Absent Innocent Acquisition; Broad Appeal Waivers Enforced While Preserved Suppression Issues Remain Reviewable 1....

Quiah (4th Cir. 2026): DUI Indicators Permit Stop Extension; Short Continuance Within One Year Does Not Trigger Speedy-Trial Relief

Date: Sep 3, 2026

Observable DUI Indicators Justify Extending a Traffic Stop for Field Sobriety Testing; A 62‑Day Continuance and a Sub‑Year Time-to-Trial Are Not “Presumptively Prejudicial” 1. Introduction United...

United States v. Yasinov: When Omitted § 111(b) Elements in a General Verdict Form Do Not Require Reversal, and When Multiple § 111(b) Counts Are Not Multiplicitous

Date: Sep 3, 2026

United States v. Yasinov: When Omitted § 111(b) Elements in a General Verdict Form Do Not Require Reversal, and When Multiple § 111(b) Counts Are Not Multiplicitous 1. Introduction In United States...

Cisco Closes the Sosa Door: Alien Tort Statute Claims Limited to the “Blackstone Three”

Date: Sep 2, 2026

Cisco Closes the Sosa Door: Alien Tort Statute Claims Limited to the “Blackstone Three” 1. Introduction In Suhail Al Shimari v. CACI Premier Technology, Inc., No. 25-1043 (4th Cir. Aug. 28, 2026)...

Lowest Unit Charge Is Limited to Candidate “Use”: Political Parties and Joint Fundraising Committees with Non‑Candidate Members Are Ineligible

Date: Aug 28, 2026

Lowest Unit Charge Is Limited to Candidate “Use”: Political Parties and Joint Fundraising Committees with Non‑Candidate Members Are Ineligible I. Introduction Case: Sherrod Brown v. FCC (4th Cir....

Fourth Circuit Rejects the “Reason-for-Vacatur” Test: A Vacated Conviction Cannot Support Inadmissibility Under 8 U.S.C. § 1182(a)(2)(A)(i)

Date: Aug 26, 2026

Fourth Circuit Rejects the “Reason-for-Vacatur” Test: A Vacated Conviction Cannot Support Inadmissibility Under 8 U.S.C. § 1182(a)(2)(A)(i) I. Introduction In Lizbeyde Piedra v. Todd Blanche (4th...

Rogers Compliance Without Express PSR Adoption: Incorporation of Standard Supervised-Release Conditions by Specific Reference, and Corroborated Controlled Buys as Relevant Conduct Despite Informant Recantation

Date: Aug 26, 2026

Rogers Compliance Without Express PSR Adoption: Incorporation of Standard Supervised-Release Conditions by Specific Reference, and Corroborated Controlled Buys as Relevant Conduct Despite Informant...

Indefinite Telework That Fully Meets Medical Limitations Defeats an ADA § 12112(b)(5)(A) Failure-to-Accommodate Claim; Retaliation for Requesting an Accommodation Is Not Per Se Disability Discrimination

Date: Aug 26, 2026

Indefinite Telework That Fully Meets Medical Limitations Defeats an ADA § 12112(b)(5)(A) Failure-to-Accommodate Claim; Retaliation for Requesting an Accommodation Is Not Per Se Disability...

Bronchodilator Reversibility Does Not Defeat Legal Pneumoconiosis: Experts Must Address Residual Impairment and Coal-Dust Aggravation

Date: Aug 26, 2026

Bronchodilator Reversibility Does Not Defeat Legal Pneumoconiosis: Experts Must Address Residual Impairment and Coal-Dust Aggravation Case: Central Appalachian Coal Company v. DOWCP (Respondent...

Fourth Circuit Recognizes Limited Authority to Continue an Ongoing Terry Stop Into a Home When a Suspect Retreats and Child-Safety Exigencies Persist

Date: Aug 26, 2026

Fourth Circuit Recognizes Limited Authority to Continue an Ongoing Terry Stop Into a Home When a Suspect Retreats and Child-Safety Exigencies Persist 1. Introduction Case: Fareed Hayat v. Casey Diaz...

ADEA Prima Facie “Legitimate Expectations” Rule: Objective Certifications and Coworker Praise Do Not Create a Jury Issue Against Documented Academy Performance and Insubordination

Date: Aug 26, 2026

ADEA Prima Facie “Legitimate Expectations” Rule: Objective Certifications and Coworker Praise Do Not Create a Jury Issue Against Documented Academy Performance and Insubordination 1. Introduction In...

Hunter “Miscarriage of Justice” Standard: Routine Guidelines Errors (and Downstream Reduction Effects) Do Not Defeat an Appeal Waiver

Date: Aug 26, 2026

Hunter “Miscarriage of Justice” Standard: Routine Guidelines Errors (and Downstream Reduction Effects) Do Not Defeat an Appeal Waiver 1. Introduction United States v. Tovis Richardson (4th Cir. Aug....

Warrantless Supervised-Release Home Searches: Reasonable Suspicion Under a Search Condition Satisfies the Fourth Amendment

Date: Aug 26, 2026

Warrantless Supervised-Release Home Searches: Reasonable Suspicion Under a Search Condition Satisfies the Fourth Amendment Introduction In United States v. Tyrell Watts (4th Cir. Aug. 20, 2026)...

Twenty-Sixth Amendment Requires Age-Neutral Access to State-Provided Voting Methods (No-Excuse Absentee-by-Mail)

Date: Aug 21, 2026

Twenty-Sixth Amendment Requires Age-Neutral Access to State-Provided Voting Methods (No-Excuse Absentee-by-Mail) Case: Trudy Grant v. Conway Belangia (No. 25-1413) — United States Court of Appeals...

Chilled Worship Attendance Establishes Standing and RFRA “Substantial Burden” Against DHS’s Sensitive-Locations Rollback

Date: Aug 21, 2026

Chilled Worship Attendance Establishes Standing and RFRA “Substantial Burden” Against DHS’s Sensitive-Locations Rollback 1. Introduction In Yearly Meeting of the Religious Society of Friends v....

United States v. Hicks & Mendoza: Sovereign-Citizen Rhetoric Alone Does Not Defeat a Faretta Waiver or Trigger a Sua Sponte Competency Hearing; Consent Waives Objections to Remote Rule 15 Testimony

Date: Aug 21, 2026

Sovereign-Citizen Rhetoric Alone Does Not Defeat a Faretta Waiver or Trigger a Sua Sponte Competency Hearing; Consent Waives Objections to Remote Rule 15 Testimony Case: United States v. Willie Hicks...

Provisional Unlawful Presence Waivers Do Not Stay Removal; § 1252(g) Allows Pure “Authority” Challenges, but “Lure-to-Arrest” Claims Require Evidence

Date: Aug 21, 2026

Provisional Unlawful Presence Waivers Do Not Stay Removal; § 1252(g) Allows Pure “Authority” Challenges, but “Lure-to-Arrest” Claims Require Evidence 1. Introduction Alyse Sanchez v. Markwayne Mullin...

Residential Search Warrants Require a Current, Particularized Nexus—Area Drug Activity and Stale Home Facts Defeat Probable Cause and Can Defeat Leon Good Faith

Date: Aug 21, 2026

Residential Search Warrants Require a Current, Particularized Nexus—Area Drug Activity and Stale Home Facts Defeat Probable Cause and Can Defeat Leon Good Faith United States v. Earl Griffin, Jr....

Fourth Circuit (Unpublished): Sovereign-Citizen Rhetoric Alone Does Not Trigger a Sua Sponte Competency Evaluation, and Consent Waives Confrontation Objections to Rule 15 Video Depositions

Date: Aug 21, 2026

Fourth Circuit (Unpublished): Sovereign-Citizen Rhetoric Alone Does Not Trigger a Sua Sponte Competency Evaluation, and Consent Waives Confrontation Objections to Rule 15 Video Depositions Case:...